Minty-Fresh Designs

 Introduction

We've all fallen victim to the power of the impulse buy: a small trinket or snack (usually right where you're checking out) that you can just toss on the pile at the last second before you leave a store. Many stores at Disneyland have adorable little tins of candy or mints available as impulse options. I'm pining for the Happiest Place on Earth as much as any other pass brat, so today, let's ask the real question: how user-friendly are these tins?

"Okay," you're probably thinking, "You've really snapped your tether this time. You're going to devote a whole blog post to mint tins?" But think about it! Everything we interact with, wear, or consume involves designs at multiple levels. I cannot think of any better way to stress the importance of good design than with something as small as mint tins.

The Good:

a chocolate mint tin
Mmmm, chocolate mints..... Ok, focus.

This tin for chocolate mints has a pretty standard design: it's rectangular, has a picture of the iconic characters, and shows how they're represented in the mints. It tells you the size of the package, as well as the flavor of the candy. Nutrition facts and ingredients are shown on the back. The real MVP of this tin's design, however, is the hinge holding the lid to the box!

back view of the tin that allows you to see the hinge

The hinge is a beautifully designed feature because it has a spring that does most of the work in opening the tin. It still clasps securely at the front, but this tin could easily be opened with one hand. The spring also holds the lid open for the user's convenience. The rectangular shape also makes this tin excellent for repurposing. It can hold business cards, pendants, or, in this case, gears!

a photo of the tin with the lid open, revealing three metal gears inside
Take a moment to admire the lid, held upright only by the spring in the hinge...

This mint tin absolutely serves its primary function, but it is also pleasant to look at, convenient for the user, and friendlier to the environment than a single-use package!

Now we'll consider another tin from Disneyland.

Needs Improvement:

I'm going to be honest: I bought this one because I love Pop art.

a mint tin with minnie mouse in a pop art style. text on the tin reads "so sweet!"

This mint tin is adorable and eye-catching: a shopper certainly would not miss this among the plethora of treasures available for purchase. The back of the tin, as with the first one, shows the nutrition facts and ingredients. The biggest difference between the two tins is that this one does not have a lovely hinge.

image showing the top of the tin fully disconnects from the bottom of the tin. a few mints are still inside the tin

As you can see, this tin is comprised of two different pieces: a top and a bottom. The top fits very snugly into the bottom, which is great, since we do not want tins dumping mints inside our pockets or purses! However, unlike the first one, this one requires much more effort to open. Admittedly, my hands are not very strong thanks to fibromyalgia, but I struggle to take this lid off with one hand!

The tin's unusual shape also makes reusing it a challenge. It is not wide enough for business cards. It might hold other things, like medications, moist towelettes, or beads, but its irregular shape would also make it difficult to stack with other mint tins. While this mint tin still serves its intended purpose well, I would argue that its design is not as user-friendly, nor as sustainably-minded.

What do you think? Am I overanalyzing everyday objects? Do you prefer mint tins without a hinge? What have you UXplored this week? Let me know in the comments, and I'll see you next week!

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Relaxation Nation

Designer, Heal Thyself

Pill Bottle Pains