Ivy League Website Design: Leading the Way?

(Week 3's Blog Post!)

Introduction

This week, our course reading featured Chapter 3 of Steve Krug's quintessential UX tome, "Don't Make Me Think (Revisited)". This chapter had several pointers on designing webpages: namely, that they should be designed like billboards, since most of us tend to read information by scanning it.

You'll notice I have even made some edits to the format of this blog, in recognition of what I have learned from this chapter. As much as I enjoy a good conversation about tangible UX, it hardly seems appropriate to try and apply web design principles to a tangible interface, so this week, I'll be analyzing two websites, one admirably-designed and another less so, based on the six principles found in Krug's writing.

The Principles at Work

An especially user-friendly experience meets the following criteria:

  1. Take advantage of conventions
  2. Create effective visual hierarchies
  3. Break pages up into clearly-defined areas
  4. Make it obvious what's clickable
  5. Eliminate Distractions
  6. Format content to support scanning

(Krug, S., 2014)

Let's examine all of these in the context of a well-done site for a famous school's art department.

The Good

There are eight east-coast schools in the Ivy League. One of these schools is Columbia University. The website for their Arts department is shown below:

a screenshot of Columbia University's school of the arts homepage


While obviously an eye-catching page with vivid colors, there is also quite a bit of information on this site. How does it rank, according to Krug?

Columbia's page takes advantage of conventions to guide the user through the page. The "search" function is in the top right corner. The name of the institution and navigation menu is on the left (#1, #4). There are easily-identifiable links on the bottom of the page (#4).

The school's name immediately appears in the top left corner, in its own unique color. From there, the eye is immediately drawn to the red box that shows the links for easy navigation (#2). Even with a bright, colorful piece of artwork, the text arranged in a way that allows it to be effective (#5). The artwork does not overwhelm the design or detract from the information (#5) The large headers also make it easy to scan quickly and find the information the user seeks. (#6). There are also clickable options at the top, and they are designed to look like buttons, to make it easier for the user (#4). While the separate areas are distinct, scrolling down makes it even more clear that each area is clearly-defined for the user to easily navigate (#3, shown below).

a scrolled-down image of columbia art department's homepage
The navigation menu even stays fixed in place

All-in-all, Columbia University's School of the Arts is a beautifully designed website. It is dynamic and striking, but has an elegant simplicity. It represents both its division and its school well, and any future or current student would find it appealing.

This balance between "appropriately artsy" and "appropriately businesslike" seems to be the common approach between six more of the Ivy League schools' art department websites. And then, you have Yale.

Needs Improvement

I was introduced to the Yale School of Art's website this week through a classmate. It's very...well, see for yourself:

a screenshot of the yale school of art home page

In Yale's defense(?), I imagine that they are trying to appeal to a very specific kind of arts student with this site design. But how does it fit with Krug's thoughts regarding a site with an ideal user experience?

(Spoiler alert: Not good.)

The page takes advantage of almost no conventions: login information is on the left, at the very bottom of the page (you have to scroll down to find it) (#1). This places it, literally, in the opposite place you would expect to find it. Link navigation is on the right side of the content, but actually in the middle of the page (#1). The visual hierarchy of the type is demolished by the background, which not only repeats in a visually-overwhelming tile pattern, but is animated (#2, #5). While the highest level of hierarchy at least has a background color, the color does not even extend between the words to unify the heading (#2). Some links are underlined, others are not, some have a background, and others do not, so finding what is clickable is a daunting task (#4). Because there is no hierarchy and it is difficult to locate things, this page is nearly impossible to scan (#6). The colors are bright and eye-catching, certainly, but the movement of the background and the extremely-high hue values of each color make the page overstimulating (#5). Thankfully, there is a button to pause the background: if you can find it.

The one bright spot in this design is that the page is broken up to represent different sections (#3, shown below). At the top of the page, you may even notice that there are "On this page" links to other sections of the page. However, each section still has the same design problems that the top of the page has.

a screenshot of Yale school of art's website that shows two distinct sections
If you're curious, I do have a migraine after writing this.

This page is absolutely creative: in fact, students are invited to make additions and changes to the site. Perhaps this overflow of designers is where the site truly fails. While an avant-garde artist might look at this page and feel their heart sing, other potential students could look at it and think, "This is Yale's site? The Yale? Yale, in Connecticut?"

And they wouldn't be wrong to wonder.

What have you UXplored this week? Have you stumbled across any crazy websites? Do you LOVE Yale's site? Let me know in the comments!

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Relaxation Nation

Designer, Heal Thyself

Pill Bottle Pains